Last hunting season, I was out in the woods with Tim in the wee hours of the morning. I was hunting with a Remington 700 BDL and had seen a deer in the far edge of the woods. We were just walking out to the hunting stand and the gun was loaded, safety on. We dropped some of our gear, peered into the woods and stayed motionless. After a few minutes, we gave up hope and approached the deer stand. Tim climbed up to the hunting stand first and was unzipping the main "door" to get in. I was on the ground and was getting ready to unload the rifle and climb up as well. First, let it be known, the I am an extremely cautious hunter. I don't take it lightly that I am out in the woods, with my loved ones, carrying a dangerous weapon. My gun is always in safe mode until I am absolutely ready to shoot it. My finger isn't even by the trigger until I am absolutely ready to shoot it. Does this contribute to the fact that I don't get many deer?? Maybe, one may say, but I am hunting with my family and maybe in a few years my children and safety is my absolute number one priority.
Anyway, I am on the ground, Tim on the ladder and I am about to unload my gun. So, I point the gun in the opposite direction and point the barrel down. I take the safety off, because I have to in order to unload it and the gun
fires out of nowhere. I immediately say "TIM - what the hell just happened??" (actually, I may have used another choice 4 letter word, but you get the point.) I start shaking and say it again, "TIM - what the HELL just happened?!" He replies, "Well, obviously you pulled the trigger." I insist that I didn't, over and over, and he finally climbs down and looks at the gun. "You had to pull the trigger." Again, I say I didn't and say my finger wasn't even near the trigger and try to convince him that it wasn't. This proceeds for a bit, I think I start crying, and we eventually make it up into the deer stand. I refuse to load the gun as I think about what just happened. Tim and I talk about it and I try to convince him that I was being safe, that I am ALWAYS safe, and that I don't know what happened. I keep shaking a bit and think about the "What if?" of the situation. What if Tim was right by me? What if he accidentally would have been hit? What if someone else was around?
What if...
What if...
What if?
Yes, I get over it ,but this has been in the back of my mind for awhile. I consider not hunting anymore because of the shock and scare this gave me. But, I enjoy it and just agree to not use this particular rifle again.
Until...
Tim and I are sitting down last night. I am typing up my blog post and he is flipping channels on the TV. I am happily writing about the Packers when Tim says, "Kel - look at this"
There is a story on CNBC about a tragedy that happened to a family out west. They were out riding horses and hunting, enjoying the day together as a family. The mother was going to unload her gun - a Remington 700 series gun - when it accidentally fired and killed her 9 year old son. The father, immersed in grief, vowed to his son to not let this go and to figure out what happened.
So - what happened?
Apparently - there are documented stories and injuries and even deaths about the Remington 700 series gun discharging. This particular story illustrated by CNBC about this family was very compelling and scary and unfortunately hit somewhat close to home. My story was not tragic in its ending, just haunting as I think back to what could have happened especially as I hear about a mother who was trying to be safe and the unthinkable happens. Her son had slid off the horse he was riding and moved to the truck or something without her knowing, and the rest is tragic.
As the Dad dug into it more, he uncovered many stories and many lawsuits about the Remington 700 series guns. He uncovered police squads, sharp shooters, and gun experts who have documented this same issue. These experts have video tapes of these guns misfiring as they have been trying to prove that they may be unsafe. There are gun experts who have studied the guns and testified at trials about these guns. Police units have videos of these guns discharging as they are on assignment. There are stories from the military about the same problem.
The worst thing?
Remington knows. The CNBC investigator spoke with the 98 year old man who designed this gun. He discovered what was causing the rifles to discharge unknowingly about
60 years ago. He alerted Remington about the issue and urged them to change the design. But, they didn't. He urged them at the time to change the triggers on these guns for a fee of $0.055 per gun, but they didn't. He even suggested changing the name of "safety" on these guns because of the trigger failure with the safety, it couldn't really be labeled as a safety. But, they didn't do that either. Now roughly 60 years later after this trigger failure was discovered, the price for Remington to fix one rifle is roughly $75 - $100. A recall would be extremely costly and no one can force Remington to do it unfortunately.
Obviously, there are two sides to the story. You know where I stand on it as this unfortunately happened to me. But, do your own research. The link to the CNBC story is:
"Critical Safety Questions at Remington Arms"
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/39762676/ns/business-cnbc_tv/Please spread the word to your friends and family that may own one of these guns. Let them do the research and decide on their own. I know many hunters and feel obligated to share this as I wouldn't be able to live with myself if something should happen and I didn't tell people.
Tim did some research as he owns 3 of these types of guns and discovered it would cost about $200 to buy a trigger on his own and replace just one. I am hoping to do some research on the class action lawsuit against Remington to see what that is about. I also found out that in 2002 Remington reluctantly decided to remodify some of the older models of these guns for a fee of $20. I will look into that as well.
Scary, scary, scary. Especially because they know! The CNBC investigator uncovered documents of Remington running tests on these rifles and they actually had this same problem happen. Anyway, please share and think about it. Even if you are fond of Remington and think this is a bunch of bunk, at least be more careful when using one. I told Tim that he would not be using one of these around me or the kids until they are fixed. I also told him that he is an old man and can decide on his own if he wants to still use it without the fix, but he shouldn't plan on us being around him. :-)
If you want more information - there is a lot of information about this on the web. Or, feel free to shoot me an email as I will be compiling some data too.
Once again - forward this or the link to anyone that hunts or owns rifles. It is definitely better to be safe than sorry when guns are concerned.